Columns

The teacher behind the teacher

Manisha Dhami

We are quick to ask whether our teachers are good enough. We question whether they can manage classrooms, engage students, use technology, encourage critical thinking and respond to the changing needs of children. When students struggle to learn or classrooms fail to engage them, the teacher is often among the first people we look at. But a teacher does not simply arrive in a classroom fully prepared. Before standing in front of a class, a teacher has already passed through a system of education, training, examinations, teaching practice and professional preparation. So perhaps, before asking what is wrong with our teachers, we need to ask a different question: “How are we preparing our teachers for the work we expect them to do?”

And if teachers are prepared by teacher educators and teacher-education institutions, then we must ask the question one level deeper: Who prepares the people who prepare our teachers? That is where the conversation about teacher quality becomes a conversation about the system that produces teacher quality.

We spend enormous energy debating what children should learn, how they should be assessed, what textbooks should contain and how schools should improve. We discuss curricula, examinations, learning outcomes, technology and educational reforms. Yet the making of the teacher often remains in the background. The teacher appears in the classroom almost as a finished product, as though acquiring a qualification automatically transforms a person into a capable professional. But teachers do not simply arrive at the classroom door. They pass through teacher education institutions, examinations, internships, training programmes, mentors and regulatory systems. Every one of these experiences contributes to the professional who eventually stands before a child. The quality of teacher education, however, is rarely examined with the same seriousness as the quality of school education. We debate what children should learn, but we rarely ask what teachers themselves are actually learning in their training programmes. Are they being taught to understand how children think, feel and develop? Are they learning to observe behaviour rather than merely manage it? Are they being prepared to recognise that a child’s ability to learn is shaped by emotional, social and cognitive development, not just by the syllabus? These questions remain largely absent from public discussion.

India has an institutional framework for teacher education. The National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE), established under the NCTE Act, 1993, is responsible for maintaining norms and standards in teacher education. The National Education Policy 2020 also places considerable emphasis on teacher preparation and continuous professional development, recognising that teachers need opportunities to continually develop their knowledge and skills rather than treating teacher education as something that ends with an initial degree. The intention is clear. But the existence of a framework does not automatically guarantee the quality of what happens within it.

A teacher may complete a BEd, pass examinations, prepare lesson plans, undertake teaching practice, attend workshops and receive a certificate. On paper, the requirements may appear to have been fulfilled. But there is a difference between completing teacher education and becoming a teacher. The former can be documented relatively easily. The latter is much more difficult to measure. A certificate can tell us that a course was completed; it cannot tell us whether a teacher has developed professional judgement, classroom sensitivity, intellectual curiosity or the ability to respond thoughtfully to different learners.

The field of child development offers a useful lens here. A child does not learn in isolation from their emotional, social and physical state. Cognitive development, language acquisition, emotional regulation and social understanding are deeply interconnected, especially in the early years. A teacher who has not been trained to understand this interconnectedness may interpret a child’s inability to concentrate as laziness, or a child’s withdrawal as disobedience, or a child’s slow reading as a lack of intelligence. Without grounding in child development, teaching risks becoming a mechanical exercise in transmitting information rather than a responsive process of nurturing learning. This distinction matters because the role of a teacher has changed. A teacher is no longer expected simply to deliver a prescribed syllabus. Teachers are expected to understand diverse learners, manage classrooms, assess learning, integrate technology, encourage critical thinking, communicate with parents and respond to behavioural and socio-emotional concerns. They are expected to teach content while simultaneously responding to the complexity of the human beings sitting in front of them. That is a demanding professional role. But how much of teacher preparation is devoted to developing the ability to make sense of that complexity?

Consider a child who repeatedly gets out of their seat. The behaviour may quickly become “indiscipline”. An adolescent who questions instructions may be described as “disrespectful”. A child who struggles academically may be labelled “weak”. Another who remains silent may simply be considered “well behaved”. Yet understanding these behaviours requires more than classroom control techniques. It requires knowledge of development, individual differences, motivation, learning, social relationships and context. If teachers are expected to understand children rather than merely control classrooms, then teacher preparation must prepare them for that responsibility. Understanding why a child behaves the way they do is not a matter of intuition; it is a matter of training.

There is also a contradiction worth examining. We tell children not to memorise blindly. We tell them to question, analyse, think independently and develop curiosity. Yet teacher education itself can sometimes become heavily focused on fulfilling prescribed requirements. Assignments are submitted, attendance is recorded, lesson plans are prepared, workshops are attended and certificates are collected. None of these activities is inherently meaningless; institutions need structure and accountability. But what happens when evidence that an activity took place becomes more important than evidence that professional learning actually occurred? A workshop attended is not necessarily a skill acquired. A lesson plan submitted is not necessarily evidence of good teaching. An examination passed is not necessarily evidence of professional competence. A certificate is evidence of completion, but it is not a complete measure of transformation.

And then there is the teacher educator, the person responsible for preparing future teachers. We rarely ask enough questions about this layer of the system. What prepares a teacher educator to prepare teachers? Expertise in a subject does not automatically translate into expertise in teaching that subject. Similarly, being an experienced teacher does not automatically mean being prepared to develop other teachers. If the quality of teachers matters, then the quality and preparation of those responsible for preparing teachers must matter too. This creates a chain that is rarely visible when educational problems are discussed. The child is taught by the teacher. The teacher is prepared by the teacher educator. The teacher educator works within an institution. The institution functions within regulatory and higher education structures. And all of these operate within broader educational policies. When something goes wrong in the classroom, however, the chain often ends at the teacher.

The teacher becomes the easiest point of blame. Poor student performance? The teacher is blamed. Classroom discipline is weak? The teacher is blamed. Students are disengaged? The teacher is blamed. Critical thinking is lacking? Again, the teacher becomes the obvious target. But professionals are also products of the systems that recruit, prepare, supervise, evaluate and support them. This does not remove individual responsibility. It simply makes the question of responsibility larger. We need to stop thinking of teacher quality as something that can be produced merely by issuing qualifications. Professional quality has to be cultivated. It requires meaningful preparation, authentic classroom experience, mentoring, reflection, continuing professional development and institutional cultures that value learning rather than mere compliance. It also requires systems capable of examining themselves.

This is where educational reform becomes complicated. It is much easier to announce a new curriculum, introduce a new examination pattern or prescribe another training module than to examine whether the institutions responsible for implementing these reforms are themselves prepared for the task. We repeatedly ask teachers to change, adapt and innovate. But who supports the teacher through that change? Who gives the teacher meaningful opportunities to learn? Who observes practice and provides feedback? Who evaluates whether professional development has actually improved teaching rather than simply increased the number of certificates in a file?

The problem with educational debates is that we tend to look for a single point of failure. Sometimes the curriculum is blamed. Sometimes examinations. Sometimes parents. Sometimes students. Increasingly, teachers become the focus. But education is not a single point system. It is an ecosystem, and what happens in a classroom is influenced by what happens many layers above it. If we genuinely want better teachers, therefore, we need to look beyond the individual teacher. We need to examine the institutions that prepare teachers, the people who train those teachers, the systems that regulate those institutions and the professional cultures that determine what counts as teacher development.

We often ask, “Why aren’t our teachers better?” The better question is: “Have we built a system capable of making them better?” Before we judge the person standing in front of the class, we must look at everything that happened before that person ever entered it. A teacher is not born in the classroom. A teacher is made long before that, in the institutions, systems and choices that shape them. If we want better teachers, we must first be willing to build a better system to make them.

(The author is a PhD in Human Development and Family Studies; views expressed are personal)

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button