Serving Indian users should mean registering under Indian law

PIONEER EDGE EDGE NEWS SERVICE
For most Indians, the digital services they use feel local. The app on their phone, the sign-up in rupees, the UPI payment at checkout. Yet many of these services are operated by companies that have no presence in India, no office here, no team here and no obligations under Indian law. In the virtual digital asset (VDA) space, this gap has become particularly visible. A large share of India’s crypto trading now takes place on offshore platforms that neither register in India nor comply with Indian tax rules, even as they actively serve Indian users and accept payments in Indian rupees.
The Companies Act, 2013, as it stands, was not designed with this situation in mind. Section 379 deals with foreign companies that establish a “place of business” in India, a concept rooted in the physical world of offices and branches. A platform that reaches millions of Indian users through an app, without any such physical footprint, falls outside this framework. It can accept Indian customers, process Indian payments and generate revenue from India without ever being treated as a company doing business in the country.
The response so far has largely been to block such platforms. Offshore crypto apps have been blocked one by one. Blocking, however, is a defensive tool. It addresses the symptom while leaving the underlying gap in corporate law untouched. This is why a new app tends to emerge whenever an older one is taken down.
The proposal is to shift the response from reactive blocking to a statutory mandate by inserting a new section into the Companies Act. Any foreign entity that provides goods, services, digital products or content to Indian users through an app, website or any other digital interface would be required, within ninety days, to either incorporate an Indian subsidiary or register as a foreign company with a “digital place of business” in India. The concept of a digital place of business is important because it updates the traditional definition of a foreign company and prevents an entity from claiming exemption simply because it has no physical office in India.
Once registered, the entity would come within the ambit of the full range of Indian laws applicable to companies doing business in the country. These include the Information Technology Act, the Consumer Protection Act and the Competition Act, along with the Goods and Services Tax, the Income Tax Act and the Significant Economic Presence framework. In the VDA context, this would also mean becoming a withholding agent for TDS under Section 393. Where an entity fails to comply, the Central Government would retain the power to block its platform and impose penalties for continued non-compliance. The threshold at which this obligation would apply, in terms of revenue, transactions or active Indian users, would be prescribed by the Central Government to ensure that small foreign businesses are not unnecessarily brought within its ambit.
India would not be the first to take this step. Australia requires foreign companies that carry on business with Australian users to register locally. The European Union’s Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation requires authorisation to serve EU customers. Dubai’s Virtual Asset Regulatory Authority applies a similar licensing requirement. In each case, the underlying principle is the same: if you serve a country’s users, you must accept its rules.
The benefits extend in several directions. For the government, the proposal would help close a widening tax gap and reduce reliance on blocking as the primary enforcement tool. For Indian platforms that already comply with the law, it would restore a level playing field by removing the structural cost advantage currently enjoyed by offshore entities. For users, it would bring offshore platforms within the scope of Indian consumer protection laws and grievance redress mechanisms. For the platforms themselves, it would provide a clear and lawful route to serving a market they already serve informally.
In sum, the proposed section would ensure that the law that applies to Indian users also applies to those who do business with them.



